The All American committee is constituted with a representative from every division, of every league, competing in MHSAA Boy's Lacrosse. In addition, there are several coaches added as at-large members because they play schools that have very high strength of schedule and, therefore, see some of the state's best players throughout the season.

It is the responsibility of every coach that has a nominee to be in contact with their league's/division's committee member.  Though every coach can speak about their players at the time of AA voting, only committee members may vote. Per the wishes of USA Lacrosse, every year, coaches interested in joining the committee will be offered a chance to serve. The goal is to have approximately 50% turnover each year.